Linux device driver ports - Breaking new ground
In my following blog post(s) I want to elaborate on recent attemtps to renew and enhance the way Linux device drivers are ported to Genode. This is highly experimental work. So be warned if you try to follow the same approach: it hasn't proved its worth yet. But first let me explain why to break new grounds at all.
Cutting device drivers out of the Linux kernel project has a long history in Genode's development. The reasons for doing so are simple. Today almost all vendors provide Linux drivers for their devices due to the huge market share of Linux in the server, mobile, and embedded markets. The Linux kernel code is publicly available under the GPLv2 in contrast to most commercial alternatives. And last but not least, documentation for a lot of devices and systems is poor or not even available. That is why the open-source code of the Linux kernel is often the single reference for the functioning of the device.
Re-using the Linux kernel's device driver code is mostly an economical decision. Writing all device drivers from scratch means to understand the whole inner working of potentially highly complex devices. You have to test extensively to discover rare cases of hardware malfunctions, and find quirks to circumvent them. There are hundreds of device drivers that build the lion's part of the millions lines of Linux kernel code. They were written and are maintained by thousands of people often employers of the hardware vendors themself. On the other side, when extracting the "black-box" of a specific Linux device driver into a dedicated Genode component with a narrow interface, we gain the whole experience of the driver-developers without loosing isolation properties, and are able to restart the driver in case of a malfunction. So isn't this the holy grail?
Well, of course taking the driver out of the Linux kernel and transplanting them into a Genode component has a catch. You have to deal with the whole complexity of the Linux kernel and tons of boilerplate code needed to stick everything together, and to provide the high degree of flexibility Linux has. But we don't necessarily need most of this glue and its flexibility, because we only want some single pieces. Anyway you have to comprehend a lot of Linux kernel code to know where to make the cut.
Over the time we learned and adapted the way how to take Linux kernel parts over at best. It started with the earliest Genode version available, which already contained the so called DDE Kit. Whereby DDE in general stands for Device Driver Environment. It consisted of an OS-independent DDE kit and a Linux-specific library that was common to all Linux device drivers and tied to a specific kernel version. While dealing with increasingly complex drivers like the former madwifi stack for Atheros chipsets, the limitations of this approach became obvious. Certain complex driver stacks needed emulation code not necessarily useful for others. The DDE Linux library became more and more complex. Moreover, the constraint of providing a library for a fixed Linux kernel version does not work in a more-and-more fragmented vendor fork landscape. The DDE kit approach got reconsidered first while porting the Intel Graphics Execution Manager. Here, a target-specific DDE was build instead. That means, necessary compilation units were identified, and for each header file referenced by it, a symbolic link got created that refered to one central emulation code header. In the process of porting all missing declarations of datatypes, variables, and functions had to be filled manually. The advantage was that you could simplify the datastructures to a minimum needed by the driver code. The downside was that it could keep you busy some days to fill the necessary declarations, not to speak about the definitions. Anyway, for a long time this approach brought successful results for porting a wide range of different x86 and ARM drivers to Genode. The introduction of the Linux kit, a tiny, but universal backend for the driver-specific DDEs, lowered the costs for new drivers a bit.
Recently, the long-term approved approach of having a manually tailored, driver-specific DDE came to its limit. The costs for doing a new port are ranging in between 1-3 person-months depending on the complexity of the subsystem. The half-life of a port on the other hand is limited, because the Linux kernel still is a rapidly moving target, at least in its driver subsystems. That means when you have to update a ported driver to a much newer Linux kernel version, you often start from the very beginning. Due to the comparatively high costs one automatically tries to keep the old code-base as long as possible. Moreover, during the actual update, the impulse to keep the former code-base and trying to adapt it to work seems likely, even if that means to keep some dead code. Last but not least the manually-tailored approach caused a fragmented landscape of Linux kernel functions inside the different DDEs, which were either copies of each other, or which differantiated in minor details. This obviously complicates maintainance and bug-fixing across different drivers.
Therefore, when rethinking the way how to port Linux drivers to Genode the following premises were made:
Lower the manual work for tailoring the driver-specific DDE
Consolidate commonly used emulation parts
Try to fit as close as possible the original semantic
The last premise was made due to the observation that people lost most time during porting work in finding the semantic gaps in between original Linux code and the emulation code.
First practical steps
Well, enough motivation talk for now. Let's directly step into the re-newed approach!
The very first step is to download and prepare the Linux kernel version that is targeted. In my case I used the slightly patched vanilla Linux kernel 5.7.0 for the MNT Reform2 as found in the reform-system-image repository. The source code location, patches and configuration are referenced in the mkkernel.sh helper script. At first the kernel gets configured and compiled as it is. Thereby, its configuration files and some headers get generated. Moreover, you get an executable kernel that serves as reference to determine the correct runtime behaviour later if debugging is necessary.
But before building the kernel, you've to tweak its configuration slightly. To not compile relevant parts as modules, but compile everything as being part of the kernel binary itself, it is necessary to deselect CONFIG_MODULES in the kernel configuration. Moreover, at least when compiled for the ARM 64-bit architecture, please deselect CONFIG_JUMP_LABEL. This is an optimization option only, which leads to the usage of asm goto inline assembler directives. These directives are incompatible when being compiled as position-independent (PIC) code. But we have to compile the Linux kernel compilation units as PIC code to be used in Genode. After finishing the configuration tweaks just build the Linux kernel inside the source tree like the following:
make ARCH=arm64 CROSS_COMPILE=/usr/local/genode/tool/current/bin/genode-aarch64- Image
One of the main ideas for the new approach was to re-use all Linux kernel headers as they are. Thereby we strongly lower the manual work to provide definitions for functions, macros, structs and variables on the one hand. A manual work that cost some days not only hours! On the other hand, we follow the goal to keep the original semantic as close as possible by re-using the original headers.
No sooner said than done. I inspected the main Makefile in the Linux kernel tree, and identified the include path order, as well as its compiler warning directives, and some additional compiler flag defines. Everything was put into a new driver target.mk Makefile:
TARGET = imx8mq_fb_drv REQUIRES = arm_v8a LIBS = base CONTRIB_DIR = $(HOME)/src/linux-7f785aec84b4be2960e4ef7f91a385ba68cad77 INC_DIR = $(CONTRIB_DIR)/arch/arm64/include INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/arch/arm64/include/generated INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/include INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/arch/arm64/include/uapi INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/arch/arm64/include/generated/uapi INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/include/uapi INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/include/generated/uapi INC_DIR += $(CONTRIB_DIR)/scripts/dtc/libfdt CC_C_OPT += -std=gnu89 -include $(CONTRIB_DIR)/include/linux/kconfig.h CC_C_OPT += -include $(CONTRIB_DIR)/include/linux/compiler_types.h CC_C_OPT += -D__KERNEL__ -DCONFIG_CC_HAS_K_CONSTRAINT=1 CC_C_OPT += -DKASAN_SHADOW_SCALE_SHIFT=3 CC_C_OPT += -Wall -Wundef -Werror=strict-prototypes -Wno-trigraphs CC_C_OPT += -Werror=implicit-function-declaration -Werror=implicit-int CC_C_OPT += -Wno-format-security -Wno-psabi CC_C_OPT += -Wno-frame-address -Wno-format-truncation -Wno-format-overflow CC_C_OPT += -Wframe-larger-than=2048 -Wno-unused-but-set-variable -Wimplicit-fallthrough CC_C_OPT += -Wno-unused-const-variable -Wdeclaration-after-statement -Wvla CC_C_OPT += -Wno-pointer-sign -Wno-stringop-truncation -Wno-array-bounds -Wno-stringop-overflow CC_C_OPT += -Wno-restrict -Wno-maybe-uninitialized -Werror=date-time CC_C_OPT += -Werror=incompatible-pointer-types -Werror=designated-init CC_C_OPT += -Wno-packed-not-aligned--
Pro-tip: if you use another Linux kernel version or another target architecture, just inspect some random .*.o.cmd file in your Linux kernel build tree. Each compilation unit leaves a corresponding .cmd file that includes the complete compiler invocation with all flags and the dependencies of the file.
To test it, I've put all compilation units that were built in my reference kernel for the i.MX specific DRM subsystem into the new target.mk file:
LX_OBJECTS = $(wildcard $(CONTRIB_DIR)/drivers/gpu/drm/imx/*.o) LX_OBJECTS += $(wildcard $(CONTRIB_DIR)/drivers/gpu/drm/imx/dcss/*.o) LX_REL_OBJ = $(LX_OBJECTS:$(CONTRIB_DIR)/%=%) SRC_C += $(LX_REL_OBJ:%.o=%.c)) vpath %.c $(CONTRIB_DIR)
And tried to build the new component. Most objects got compiled without grumbling, but few compilation units hesitated to compile because of a missing definition named KBUILD_MODNAME. Inside the Makefiles distributed in the subdirectories of the Linux kernel, there are definitions that assign compilation units to kernel modules. On the other hand those module names are given as global defines to the compiler, like for instance:
-DKBUILD_MODFILE='"drivers/gpu/drm/imx/dcss/imx-dcss"' -DKBUILD_BASENAME='"dcss_drv"' -DKBUILD_MODNAME='"imx_dcss"'
Assuming that it is not necessarily relevant to provide the exact module name, but an indistinguishable name only, I decided to use the compilation unit's name itself as module name, and to provide the missing defines to all compilation units. Therefore I added the following directives to my target.mk file:
define CC_OPT_LX_RULES = CC_OPT_$(1) = -DKBUILD_MODFILE='"$(1)"' -DKBUILD_BASENAME='"$(notdir $(1))"' -DKBUILD_MODNAME='"$(notdir $(1))"' endef $(foreach file,$(LX_REL_OBJ),$(eval $(call CC_OPT_LX_RULES,$(file:%.o=%))))
I know it doesn't look nice, but with this little make magic in place, I was successful in compiling and linking all Linux kernel compilation units together that I liked without any error nor warning. I was overwhelmed in a positive way, because these few steps worked after few hours only, even faster than I expected before.
You might wonder why I did not see any "missing references" errors from the linker, but as I didn't called any Linux kernel code, the linker just throwed away everthing that was not needed.
The next step was to call the right initialization routines in the kernel code, and to track and automatically generate missing references. But this is another story that will be part of a later blog post.